brand was already reduced and louis williams was coming of an injury.
He can't be reduced again? In the 5 years since his injury he's averaged 12 and 7 in 29 minutes per game. That's not deserving of an 80. It doesn't matter how many rating adjustments a player has already had.
PG - Goran Dragic | SG - Terrence Ross | SF - Maurice Harkless | PF - Enes Kanter | C - Jonas Valanciunas
The trade will still stand, and I still accept it.
When I set up this new league I initially pointed all veteran GMs in the direction of this welcome thread which relates to this trade quite clearly:
Player Ratings: the same ratings will be ported over from D5. I will try to make Stock Watch Discussion requested changes as soon as possible.
I also posted similar notices back at D5 for quite some time in advance.
It would be more unfair to Troy Bolton if we now rejected the trade or cancelled it. So the trade stands and, as of this moment, is passed, unless the Trade Committee decide to reject it before I move it to the Accepted Trades section - I will clarify this point in the rules also.
On the side-point of Trade Committee members being able to change their votes. I believe TC members should definitely be allowed to change their votes whilst a trade is still in this section and, whilst that's not been written as a rule, it's actually always been the case. I am going to amend the rules to properly clarify it though.
I'll put in an official Reject, as I hinted I would have. If someone changes their mind, then it could get rejected with myself and Barber on the reject side.
I'm going to change my vote to reject this trade. Breaking it down separate from ratings I'd value the players like this:
Louis Williams > Ray Allen Elton Brand > Rashard Lewis Gustavo Ayon > Joel Anthony
Then there is the 1st round pick on top of that. If both GMs really wanted it then that would be one thing, but forcing a borderline trade on a GM isn't the best move imo. It's all about having a little fun after all.
PG - Goran Dragic | SG - Terrence Ross | SF - Maurice Harkless | PF - Enes Kanter | C - Jonas Valanciunas